Reply to comment

Firefox 2.0 RC3 Vs. Internet Explorer 7 (Final)

I just downloaded the RC3 Version of Firefox 2.0 (For Mac) and decided to try it out. So far I think it's an enormous improvement over 1.5. And It's still a fair bit ahead of IE7.

I will list a few of the things that I noticed about Firefox right away:

  • Integrated spell checking - When filling out web forms (Like this blog) Firefox will underline in red any misspelled words. I've wanted this feature badly for as long as I've been using the Internet, and I have to tell you that by itself this single feature is enough to keep me using Firefox. The new Internet Explorer 7 does not have this.
  • Better Looking Tabs - The appearance & usability of the Tab Bar has been improved. The new tabs are rounded, and hey they just look better than they did before. They also feature a small close button on each tab, rather than one button on the far right side of the tab bar. One of the features added in the just released IE7 is "Tabbed Browsing", but the tabs don't look as good to me as they do in Firefox 2.0. They have a really  fake glassy look about them.
  • Better looking fonts & controls - I'm not sure why, and I can't even be positive there is any significant difference, but the text and buttons look better to me then they did in Firefox 1.5. I'll try to do a side by side comparison later and post the results, meanwhile the users can decide if I'm crazy or not.
  • Anti-Phishing Technology - Both Firefox and The new IE7 have Anti-Phishing tech. But the way it's implemented is very different in IE7 then in Firefox 2.0. 

Firefox maintains a list of known or suspected Phishing web sites on your local computer, it will update this list every half an hour or so.

When you visit a website, it checks the address against this list and if it finds a match it warns you.

NO INFORMATION ABOUT THE WEBSITE YOU ARE VISITING (OR TRYING TO VISIT) IS TRANSMITTED TO ANYONE.

On IE7 however,  every url you visit is transmitted to a server on the Internet (one of Microsoft's servers presumably) and your web browser waits for a reply from this server letting it know if it should warn you or not.

This method is much slower than the method Firefox uses (Because it has to wait on the servers reply before it can load the page), not to mention the fact that every web site you visit is transmitted to Microsoft (or other unknown third parties) this sounds like a very very bad idea to me.

How do we know what Microsoft is planning on doing with the enormous amount of data this process must collect. This is yet another example of Microsoft invading the privacy of it's users.

It's roughly analogous to the function that "Windows Genuine Advantage" performs only on a much much larger scale. I can tell you that I wont be using this feature of IE7 at all after learning how it works.

Conclusion: After using each new browser for a rather short time, it's very clear to me that Firefox 2.0 is still the superior choice for browsing the web. (In My Opinion) Internet Explorer v 7 is a big improvement over the previous version (IE6) and if you insist on using IE then I strongly recommend that you install it.

But it doesn't have any features that Firefox is missing that I can see, and there are serious privacy concerns surrounding the Anti-Phishing support in IE7. For me this (and spell checking) is enough to prevent IE7 from usurping Firefox as my default browser.

Reply

The content of this field is kept private and will not be shown publicly.
  • Allowed HTML tags: <a> <em> <strong> <small> <sup> <sub> <cite> <blockquote> <code> <ul> <ol> <li> <dl> <dt> <dd> <h1> <h2> <h3> <h4> <img> <br> <p> <div> <span> <b> <i> <tbody> <tr> <td> <table> <hr> <u> <strike> <pre> <address>
  • Web page addresses and e-mail addresses turn into links automatically.
  • Use <fn>...</fn> to insert automatically numbered footnotes.

More information about formatting options

CAPTCHA
This extra step is necessary to block spammers.